Abandoned Lib/E (Jennie McGrady Mysteries) by Patricia H Rushford

There’s something undeniably compelling about a mystery that keeps you guessing until the very end—especially when it’s wrapped in the emotional turmoil of a young protagonist navigating faith, family, and danger. Abandoned Lib/E, part of Patricia H. Rushford’s beloved Jennie McGrady Mysteries, delivers exactly that. This Christian YA thriller blends suspense, personal growth, and moral dilemmas into a story that’s as thought-provoking as it is entertaining.

If you love clean YA mysteries with strong female leads, faith-based undertones, and well-crafted whodunits, Abandoned is a must-read. But does it hold up against modern YA thrillers? Let’s dive in.

---

Jennie McGrady, the intrepid teenage sleuth at the heart of this series, is back—and this time, the mystery hits close to home. When her cousin Lisa vanishes without a trace, Jennie refuses to believe it’s just another runaway case. The police seem ready to dismiss it, but Jennie’s instincts tell her something darker is at play.

As she digs deeper, she uncovers unsettling secrets about Lisa’s life—a troubled past, questionable friendships, and a possible connection to a dangerous underground world. The investigation leads Jennie through a maze of lies, where even those closest to Lisa might be hiding something.

Rushford masterfully balances suspense and realism, avoiding over-the-top theatrics while keeping the stakes high. The pacing is tight, with just enough red herrings to keep readers engaged without feeling misled.

(No major spoilers here—but trust me, the twists are worth it.)

---

Jennie McGrady isn’t your typical fearless detective. She’s smart but impulsive, faithful but questioning, and deeply loyal but sometimes reckless. Her flaws make her feel real—she makes mistakes, doubts herself, and struggles with fear, yet she never gives up.

What sets Jennie apart from other YA sleuths is her moral compass. Unlike darker, grittier protagonists, Jennie’s faith plays a crucial role in her decisions. She wrestles with ethical dilemmas—when to trust authority, how far to push boundaries for the truth, and whether vengeance ever justifies action.

Supporting characters, like her family and friends, add depth without overshadowing Jennie’s journey. Lisa, in particular, is more than just a plot device—her backstory makes her disappearance feel personal, raising the emotional stakes.

---

Rushford’s prose is accessible yet engaging, making this a great pick for both teens and adults. The first-person perspective keeps us locked in Jennie’s head, experiencing her fears and triumphs firsthand.

The dialogue feels natural, and the investigative scenes are detailed without bogging down the pace. Rushford avoids info-dumping, instead letting clues unfold organically. Some readers might find the Christian themes prominent, but they’re woven in naturally rather than feeling preachy.

One standout technique is how Rushford builds tension. Instead of relying on cheap jump scares, she crafts unease through subtle details—a strange phone call, an offhand comment, a character acting just a little too innocent.

---

Beyond the mystery, Abandoned explores weighty themes:

• Faith in Crisis – Jennie’s belief is tested as she faces evil head-on.
• Moral Ambiguity – When does justice cross into vengeance?
• Family Loyalty – How far would you go for someone you love?

The book doesn’t offer easy answers, making it a great discussion starter for book clubs or teen groups.

---

I’ll admit, I picked this up expecting a light mystery—but Abandoned surprised me. The emotional weight of Jennie’s journey, the realistic portrayal of teen struggles, and the genuinely unpredictable ending left me thinking long after I finished.

One scene, in particular, stands out:

"Sometimes the hardest thing isn’t finding the truth—it’s deciding what to do with it."

That line encapsulates the book’s heart. It’s not just about solving a case; it’s about what the solution costs.

---

Fans of Nancy Drew or Trixie Belden will appreciate Jennie’s classic sleuthing style, but with a modern, faith-based twist. Compared to darker YA thrillers like One of Us Is Lying, Abandoned is lighter on violence but just as gripping.

If you enjoy clean mysteries with depth, this is a standout.

---

✅ Strengths:

• Well-developed, relatable protagonist
• Tight, engaging mystery with real stakes
• Faith elements enhance rather than distract
• Great for readers who want suspense without gore

❌ Minor Weaknesses:

• Some secondary characters could be fleshed out more
• The pacing slows slightly in the middle
• The resolution, while satisfying, may feel abrupt to some

---

• Teens & Adults who enjoy clean, faith-based mysteries
• Fans of Christian fiction looking for suspense
• Parents & educators seeking engaging, morally thoughtful YA

---

Abandoned Lib/E is more than just a whodunit—it’s a story about courage, faith, and the messy pursuit of justice. Rushford delivers a mystery that’s both entertaining and meaningful, making it a standout in the genre.

🔗 Get the Book: Amazon

Discussion Question: What’s a mystery novel that surprised you with its depth? Share your favorites in the comments!

Get this book on Amazon

For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.

For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.