Book Review Al Capone Does My Shirts (Tales from Alcatraz)

Imagine growing up on Alcatraz Island—home to the most notorious criminals in America—where your neighbors include mobsters like Al Capone. Now, picture being a 12-year-old boy navigating the challenges of family, school, and a sister who doesn’t fit into society’s expectations. Al Capone Does My Shirts by Gennifer Choldenko is a middle-grade historical fiction novel that blends humor, heartbreak, and history into an unforgettable coming-of-age story.

This book isn’t just about life on Alcatraz; it’s about love, responsibility, and what it means to stand up for those you care about. Whether you're a young reader, a parent, or simply a fan of historical fiction, this novel offers something profound. Let’s dive into why Al Capone Does My Shirts is a must-read.

---

Set in 1935, the story follows Moose Flanagan, a 12-year-old boy whose family moves to Alcatraz Island when his father takes a job as an electrician and prison guard. Moose’s older sister, Natalie, has autism (though it’s never explicitly named, given the era’s limited understanding of neurodivergence), and his parents hope a special school in San Francisco will help her.

Life on Alcatraz is anything but ordinary. Moose befriends the warden’s mischievous daughter, Piper, who constantly drags him into schemes—including a wild rumor that Al Capone does the inmates’ laundry (hence the title). Meanwhile, Moose struggles with his responsibilities toward Natalie, his parents’ strained marriage, and the pressure of fitting in at school.

Without giving away major spoilers, the novel’s climax hinges on Moose’s desperate attempt to secure Natalie’s future—a moment that’s both heartbreaking and hopeful.

---

Moose is an incredibly relatable protagonist. He’s kind but frustrated, responsible yet yearning for a normal childhood. His love for Natalie is unwavering, even when he resents the burden of caring for her. His growth—from resentment to fierce protectiveness—is one of the book’s most compelling arcs.

Natalie is portrayed with sensitivity and depth. Her autism manifests in repetitive behaviors, difficulty with social cues, and an extraordinary talent for numbers. Choldenko avoids stereotypes, instead showing Natalie as a complex individual who challenges her family and society’s expectations.

Piper is a scene-stealer—charismatic, manipulative, but ultimately loyal. Her schemes add humor, but she also serves as a foil to Moose, pushing him out of his comfort zone.

Moose’s parents are realistically flawed. His mother is in denial about Natalie’s condition, while his father is more pragmatic but distant. Their struggles mirror Moose’s internal conflict, making the family dynamics deeply moving.

---

Choldenko’s prose is accessible yet rich, blending humor with poignant moments. The first-person narration immerses readers in Moose’s world, making Alcatraz feel alive—from the eerie prison sounds to the tight-knit community of families living on the island.

The dialogue crackles with authenticity, especially between the kids. Historical details are woven seamlessly into the story, never feeling like a textbook aside.

---

At its core, this is a story about unconditional love. Moose’s journey forces him to grapple with duty versus desire, while his parents’ choices highlight the sacrifices made for family.

Natalie’s character challenges 1930s attitudes toward disability. The book subtly critiques societal exclusion while celebrating neurodiversity.

Moose struggles with his place—on Alcatraz, at school, and within his family. His arc is about finding strength in his unique circumstances.

---

I laughed at Piper’s antics, ached for Moose’s struggles, and cried at the raw emotional moments. The ending, in particular, is powerful without being melodramatic. Choldenko doesn’t offer easy answers, making the story feel authentic.

---

Fans of Wonder by R.J. Palacio or Counting by 7s by Holly Goldberg Sloan will appreciate the themes of difference and resilience. The historical setting also echoes The War That Saved My Life by Kimberly Brubaker Bradley.

---

✅ Strengths:

• Unique, immersive setting
• Complex, relatable characters
• Perfect balance of humor and heart
• Thoughtful portrayal of autism (ahead of its time for the 1930s setting)

❌ Weaknesses (Minor):

• Some readers might want more resolution for certain subplots
• Piper’s schemes occasionally feel repetitive

---

• Middle-grade readers (ages 10+) who enjoy historical fiction
• Parents & educators looking for books about empathy and family
• Fans of heartfelt, character-driven stories

---

"Today I moved to Alcatraz, a twelve-acre rock covered with cement, topped with bird turd and surrounded by water."

"It’s funny how you can forget everything except the thing you want to forget the most."

---

The 1930s were a time when disabilities like autism were poorly understood. Natalie’s struggles reflect real societal barriers. Alcatraz’s history as a prison adds a fascinating backdrop, grounding the story in a unique moment in time.

---

Al Capone Does My Shirts is more than a kids' book—it’s a touching, funny, and deeply human story about love, acceptance, and resilience. Whether you’re young or just young at heart, this book will stay with you long after the last page.

🔗 Get the Book: Amazon

---

1. How does Moose’s relationship with Natalie change throughout the book?
2. Do you think Piper is a good friend to Moose? Why or why not?
3. How does the Alcatraz setting enhance the story?

Have you read Al Capone Does My Shirts? What did you think? Share your thoughts below!

Get this book on Amazon

For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.

For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.