Book Review Anne of Green Gables, Complete 8-Book Box Set

There are few literary heroines as enduring and beloved as Anne Shirley, the fiery-haired, imaginative orphan who captures hearts from the very first page. Anne of Green Gables and its sequels by L. M. Montgomery have enchanted readers for over a century, weaving a tapestry of warmth, humor, and poignant life lessons. This complete 8-book box set offers the full journey of Anne’s life—from her arrival at Green Gables as a spirited girl to her growth into a wise and compassionate woman.

Whether you're revisiting Avonlea or discovering it for the first time, this review will explore why Montgomery’s masterpiece remains a cornerstone of children’s literature and a treasure for readers of all ages.

---

The series begins with Anne of Green Gables, where siblings Marilla and Matthew Cuthbert of Prince Edward Island expect to adopt a boy to help with farm work—but instead, they receive Anne, a talkative, dreamy girl with an irrepressible imagination. Though initially hesitant, they come to love her, and Anne’s adventures unfold in the idyllic (and sometimes dramatic) world of Avonlea.

Subsequent books follow Anne through adolescence (Anne of Avonlea), her teaching years (Anne of the Island), marriage (Anne’s House of Dreams), motherhood (Anne of Ingleside), and even her children’s stories (Rainbow Valley and Rilla of Ingleside). The final book, Rilla of Ingleside, shifts focus to Anne’s youngest daughter during World War I, offering a poignant historical perspective.

Montgomery’s storytelling is episodic yet deeply connected, blending humor, heartbreak, and the quiet beauty of everyday life.

---

Anne is a literary force—a character so vivid she feels real. Her flaws (temper, vanity, impulsiveness) make her relatable, while her virtues (loyalty, creativity, resilience) make her inspiring. She grows from a melodramatic child into a thoughtful woman, yet never loses her spark.

Gilbert begins as Anne’s academic rival (infamous for calling her “carrots”), but their relationship evolves into one of literature’s most beloved slow-burn romances. His steady kindness contrasts Anne’s fiery spirit, making them perfect foils.

Marilla’s stern exterior hides deep love, while Matthew’s quiet support is one of the series’ most touching elements. Their growth into parental figures is beautifully rendered.

Anne’s best friend embodies unwavering friendship, even when Anne’s antics lead to mishaps (like the infamous raspberry cordial incident).

Montgomery populates Avonlea with memorable side characters, from the gossipy Rachel Lynde to the tragic yet poetic Ruby Gillis. Each feels fully realized, contributing to the series’ rich tapestry.

---

Montgomery’s prose is lush and evocative, painting Prince Edward Island in vivid detail:

“The Lake of Shining Waters was blue—blue—blue; not the changeful blue of spring, nor the pale azure of summer, but a clear, steadfast, serene blue.”

Her third-person omniscient narration allows intimate access to characters’ thoughts while maintaining a nostalgic, almost fairy-tale-like tone. The dialogue sparkles with humor, particularly Anne’s dramatic monologues.

However, some modern readers may find the pacing slow by today’s standards. The books thrive on small moments rather than high-stakes plots, which is part of their charm but may not suit those craving constant action.

---

Anne’s imagination is both her refuge and her superpower. Montgomery celebrates creativity while gently showing its limits (e.g., Anne’s early tendency to prioritize fantasy over reality).

Anne’s journey from orphan to cherished daughter, wife, and mother underscores that family is chosen, not just inherited.

Ahead of its time, the series portrays Anne as both romantic and ambitious. She values education, pursues a career, and balances marriage with personal growth—a progressive message for 1908.

Prince Edward Island’s landscapes are almost sentient in Montgomery’s writing, reflecting emotions and symbolizing beauty in the mundane.

---

Reading Anne’s story feels like coming home. As a child, I adored her whimsy; as an adult, I appreciate Montgomery’s nuanced portrayal of grief, love, and resilience. The later books, especially Rilla of Ingleside, carry unexpected emotional weight, depicting war’s impact on a tight-knit community.

Some minor weaknesses:

• Later books (like Anne of Windy Poplars) rely heavily on letter-writing, which can feel disjointed.
• The shift to Anne’s children in later installments may disappoint readers deeply attached to Anne’s perspective.

Yet, these are small quibbles in an otherwise masterful series.

---

Fans of Little Women will find similar themes of girlhood and growth, though Anne’s voice is distinctly more whimsical. The pastoral charm aligns with Heidi or The Secret Garden, but Montgomery’s wit and emotional depth set her apart.

---

• Lovers of classic literature seeking rich character studies.
• Parents and educators looking for wholesome yet profound stories for young readers.
• Anyone in need of comfort—Anne’s world is a balm for the soul.

---

• “Tomorrow is always fresh, with no mistakes in it yet.”
• “Kindred spirits are not so scarce as I used to think.”
• “I’m so glad I live in a world where there are Octobers.”

---

Published in 1908, Anne of Green Gables reflects early 20th-century rural Canada but transcends its era. Its exploration of gender roles, mental health (Marilla’s repressed emotions, Anne’s anxiety), and war’s toll (Rilla of Ingleside) remains strikingly relevant.

---

This 8-book box set is a treasure trove of humor, heart, and timeless wisdom. Whether you’re meeting Anne for the first time or revisiting an old friend, Montgomery’s work is a celebration of life’s small, radiant moments.

🔗 Get the Book: Amazon

Discussion Questions:

• Which Anne book resonated with you the most?
• How does Anne’s character evolve over the series?
• Do you prefer the early, whimsical Anne or the mature, reflective Anne?

Let’s chat in the comments—after all, as Anne would say, “A bosom friend is a kindred spirit!”

Get this book on Amazon

For more great reviews and book recommendations, visit Books By Order.

For more great reviews, visit Book Book Owl.